| 2021 Season |
| |
| Event | Team |
| | |
| NSA 15U World Series Champions | West Seneca Magic (Lucas) |
| WS Magic Pumpkin Smash Tourney Silver Champion | West Seneca Magic (Lucas) |
| 2021 West Seneca Tournament Champions | West Seneca Magic (Vanderlip) |
| 2021 Sports Force Park Stars and Stripes Finalist | West Seneca Magic (Vanderlip) |
| 2021 Greater Buffalo NSA National Qualifier Finalist | West Seneca Magic (Vanderlip) |
| Lakeshore “Girls of Summer” tournament silver bracket winner | West Seneca Magic (McCann / Costa) |
| Metro A Division League Season Champions (9-2-1 record) | West Seneca Magic (McCann / Costa) |
| 2nd Place in 2020 Pumpkin Smash | West Seneca Magic (Mesi) |
| 1st Place in Silver Division in the 2021 Orchard Park tournament | West Seneca Magic (Mesi) |
| 1st Place in Gold Division in the 2021 NT Jaxx tournament | West Seneca Magic (Mesi) |
| 1st Place in 2021 NFL Silver league | West Seneca Magic (Mesi) |
| Pony PlayDay Champions | West Seneca Magic (Hagler) |
| Lou Gehrig tournament: Silver Bracket Finalist | West Seneca Magic (Hagler) |
| 2021 Orchard Park Fall Frenzy 12u Silver Champions
| West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| 10U MGSL- A League Champions | West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| Girls of Summer tournament, Gold Bracket Finalist | West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| Semi Finalist Olean Synergy Tournament | West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| Semi Finalist West Seneca 10U Tournament | West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| Rochester Lady Lions Invitational Tournament Runner-Up | West Seneca Magic (Griffey) |
| Cayuga Gamblers Fall Frenzy Champions | West Seneca Magic (Rogowski) |
| West Seneca Magic 14u Tourney Champions | West Seneca Magic (Rogowski) |
| 16u Pinnacle Winter Fest Runner-Up | West Seneca Magic (Rogowski) |